Best Pizza in Cudahy

Q: Where are you located?

We are located in Cudahy, WI at 2914 E Grange Ave

Hand Tossed, House Made, and Born in the Heart of Cudahy

Order online

Featured

View menu

The Pizza Cudahy Comes Home To

Hand-tossed dough, house-made sauce, and real ingredients — this is the pizza Cudahy has been ordering for years. Whether it's a Friday night with the family, a game day with friends, or just a well-deserved slice after a long week, Pizza Pete's delivers. Weekly deals that actually make sense for your budget, and a menu that never gets old.

Order Now

Deals That Actually Make Your Week Better

At Pizza Pete's, the specials are part of the culture. Kick off the week with Meal Deal Monday — a pizza, wings, and a 2-liter for one great price. Double down on Tuesday with 2 for Tuesday, where you buy one appetizer and get one free. Hit the midweek reset with Wacky Wednesday — $2 jumbo slices with one topping, no excuses needed. And wrap up the week right with $2 off any sub on Thursdays. Regulars already know. Now you do too.

See This Week's Deals

Made Fresh, Every Time

From crispy thin crust to deep dish perfection — take a look at what Cudahy keeps coming back for.

A Tribute to Pete's Dream

Pizza Pete's was founded to honor the memory of Peter Einwiller—a Vietnam veteran, Grateful Dead fan, and beloved Cudahy resident whose dream was to own a neighborhood pizza shop. After Pete passed away in 2000, his children brought that dream to life by opening Pizza Pete's, creating a place where great food, family, and community come together.

I love wings, and I was starting to believe that no one had meaty wings anymore. Nope! Pizza Pete's has the tastiest, meatiest wings I have ever had! And my super picky son LOVES the pizza! To finish it off, they make their own cannoli! And those are delicious too! It's clear everything is made with love!

Sandy F.

I called Pizza Pete's earlier in spring about potentially catering for my wedding in August and they asked that I called back a week or two prior to finalize our counts, to my disbelief the manager remembered our conversation and took care of us in a timely fashion. Our food was delivered during their off hours to accommodate our wedding reception.

Claudia C.

We live in the neighborhood and have tried this place a while ago and decided to try again. Husband was impressed with hand tossed pizza, sauce has good flavor. Cheesy garlic was good. Boneless chicken wings with dry rub on the breading was great, generous pieces too! We will Definitely be ordering again!

Natalie R.

First time trying this place, will NOT be the last. Food was awesome, price was right. Best stuffed crust I ever had. The fresh breaded mushrooms were amazing, and I don’t like mushrooms. Will recommend to everyone!

Jared Z.

Good Vibes, Great Pizza

Pizza Pete's is the kind of place where the pizza is always good and the people are even better. A laid-back atmosphere, friendly faces, and an easygoing spirit that makes everyone feel right at home — whether you're stopping in or ordering to your door. No fuss, no frills, just honest pizza and real hospitality in the heart of Cudahy, WI. Enjoyed your visit? We'd love to hear about it — find us on Google to leave a review or get directions!

Find Us on Google

Real Rewards for Real Regulars ⭐

At Pizza Pete's, loyalty has its perks. Join our rewards program, earn points with every online order, and redeem them for free food. It's our way of saying thanks for keeping Cudahy's favorite pizza spot going strong.

Join Pizza Pete's Rewards