Pizza Pete’s | Our Story

A Tribute to Pete's Dream

Pizza Pete's was founded to honor the memory of Peter Einwiller—a Vietnam veteran, Grateful Dead fan, and beloved Cudahy resident whose dream was to own a neighborhood pizza shop. After Pete passed away in 2000, his children brought that dream to life by opening Pizza Pete's, creating a place where great food, family, and community come together.

The Pizza We're Proud Of

Every pizza at Pizza Pete's starts with hand-tossed dough, homemade sauce, and fresh, quality ingredients made in-house. From crispy thin crust to rich Chicago-style deep dish and stuffed favorites, every order is crafted with care. Our famous deep dish takes a little longer — buttery, flaky crust layered with cheese, toppings, and sauce, baked fresh to order. The wait is worth every bite.

Cudahy's Pizza, Delivered Your Way

Whether you're ordering delivery, grabbing takeout, or stopping in for a slice in Cudahy, WI, Pizza Pete's makes it easy to enjoy your favorites. Friendly service, generous portions, and weekly deals that keep locals coming back — this is the pizza Cudahy comes home to.

Good Times, Great Pizza

Pizza Pete's has always been about more than just food — it's about the people, the neighborhood, and the good times that bring everyone together. Pete was known for his love of music, community, and a good time, and that energy lives on at the restaurant every day. Whether you're a longtime regular or ordering for the first time, you'll always feel the spirit he left behind. Come as you are — Pete would have wanted it that way.